1-407-575-5392
Menu

HOA and Parking

NEXT
PREV
  Follow me: Wendy Morris on Twitter Wendy Morris on Facebook Wendy Morris on LinkedIn
Mon, Jan 28, 2019 at 10:41AM

HOA and Parking

Enforceability of Association Parking Restrictions Related to Public Streets ?

A VERY HOT TOPIC 

Many community association declarations contain restrictions on the parking of vehicles on streets located within the community.  For communities that contain private streets maintained by the association, it seems clear that these restrictions would be enforceable.  However, for communities that contain public streets, the enforceability of those restrictions is not so clear.

There appears to be no reported decision by a Florida appellate court dealing with the issue of whether a community association can enforce restrictions purporting to prohibit parking on public streets.  However, that may soon change.

A trial court, in Pinellas County, has ruled that a homeowners association cannot enforce such parking restrictions relating to public streets.  That case arose from the filing of a lawsuit by the impacted owners which sought the entry of an injunction prohibiting the association from enforcing a parking restriction relating to public streets.  The trial court granted that injunction.  The association that was a party to that case filed an appeal with the Florida Second District Court of Appeal. 

In Woodfield Community Association, Inc. v. Ortiz by and through Ortiz, 2018 WL 3403387 (Fla. 2d DCA 2018), the appellate court set aside the injunction, but only on the basis that the trial court’s order failed to include certain information needed to support entry of an injunction.  The appellate court did not discuss the underlying issue of whether the injunction would have been sustained, on its merits, had the trial court listed the necessary information.  Instead, that issue would need to be presented to the appellate court by the filing of a new appeal after the trial court enters a new order.

If such an order is entered by the trial court and the association files another appeal, Florida’s Second District Court of Appeal will be in a position to author the first Florida appellate court opinion as to the enforceability of parking restrictions relating to public streets.There are at least 3 reported decisions, from out-of-state appellate courts, that have addressed this issue. In one of the cases,

Raintree of Albemarle Homeowners Association, Inc., 413 S.E. 340 (Va. 1992), the court ruled that such restrictions could not be enforced.  In the other two cases,

Maryland Estates Homeowners’ Association v. Puckett, 936 S.W. 2d 218 (Mo. Ct. App. 1996); and Verna v. The Links at Valleybrook Neighborhood Association, Inc., 852 S. 2d 202 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. 2004), the courts ruled that such restrictions could be enforced, at least as to owners in the community.

The argument to support a finding that these restrictions are not enforceable is that an entity, such as a community association, does not have the authority to control access to or the use of a road that is owned by a municipality.  The argument to support the enforceability of these restrictions is that parties, such as an association and its owners, are free to enter into a contract (the recorded deed restrictions) containing restrictions that would impose greater limits on an owner’s use of property than those imposed by governmental restrictions.

We are not against HOAs in fact support them but of late several have pushed owners over the egde locally and righfully fighting back. What are your thoughts ?


Bookmark & Share



User Comments


Be the first to comment on this post below!


Popular tags on this blog

Al Capone | Bella Collina | Broker Associate Wendy Morris Realty | Celebrity Homes | Disney News | Drones | Foreclosure | For Sale Cannon EOS 7D Cameras Plus all the Lens | Hamilton Gardens Winter Garden Ryan Homes | How to Price your Home for Sale in Orlando Fl | Landlord | ORLANDO HOUSING MARKET REPORT - AUGUST 2018 | Orlando Market Reports | Orlando Penthouses | Queen of Versailles Jacqueline Siegel | David Siegel Windermere Lake Butler Sound | STAR WARS GALAXY?S EDGE | Summerport Windermere Fl | Taylor Swift | Waterfront Homes Clermont | Wendy Morris | Wendy Morris Realty | Wendy Morris Realty Marketing | Wendy Morris Realty Ocala | Whitney Isles Windermere Home For Sale | Windermere Fl |


All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independent verified. Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law. The source of the listing data is as follows: | Stellar MLS (updated 8/18/19)

Listing Search



Translate Tool

Featured Listings
Windermere Real Estate
$2,995,000
4 BED
5 BATH
Welcome to this gorgeous lake front home! Lake views compliment this spectacular Isleworth home that has a completely re... Read More
Windermere Real Estate
$2,325,000
3 BED
3 BATH
Old Florida living with modern luxuries! With nearly 2 acres on Lake Butler, this beautifully renovated mid-century hom... Read More
Windermere Real Estate
$1,985,000
5 BED
5.5 BATH
Lake Butler access!!! Stunning Contemporary and modern style home builded in 2017 in the amazing gated Waterstone Commun... Read More
Clermont Real Estate
$375,000
3 BED
2 BATH
NO HOA! Located at the end of the road, this property is 7.3 acres of peace and quiet and a nature-lover''s dream! The ... Read More
Clermont Real Estate
$499,000
3 BED
3 BATH
RARE DIRECT DOUBLE WATERFRONT!! Chain of Lakes, South Shore of Lake Minnehaha 1/2 ACRE!! This property has almost a 2 ... Read More
Contact Wendy Morris

407-575-5392

Wendy Morris LLC
DBA Wendy Morris Realty
Licensed in the State of Florida
BK 3146762
14832 Speer Lake Drive
Winter Garden, FL 34787

Your privacy is our utmost concern. We will never sell your personal information. Privacy Policy
©2011 -2019 windermerehomes.net - all rights reserved. | Site Map